Why do the student protests seem different this year?

June 2022 marks seven years since the 2015 #FeesMustFall movement erupted across the country – resulting in deaths and protests. The protest focused on free education, decolonization education and outsourcing work. Seven years later, the demands of the protesters have changed, as has the reaction to them

In 2021 and 2022, with universities mainly doing blended learning as a result of the Covid-19 regulations, there were not many student protests because most of them did not attend classes fully and immediately. However, with the start of the 2023 academic year, they are fully back to face-to-face learning. And thus, there have been several protests at the University of Cape Town, the Cape Peninsula University of Technology and, most recently, the University of the Witwatersrand, the University of Johannesburg, the Tshwane University of Technology and the University of KwaZulu-Natal.

This time the demand is different. The free education policy implemented by former president Jacob Zuma in 2017 has not worked. Every year hundreds of students do not have a place to continue their studies. The reason is that the government has implemented the policy of free education but has not solved the big problem of historical debt and missing center. The problem of corruption and maladministration in the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS) has also not been resolved.

Historic debt is the balance of fees owed by NSFAS-funded students, which is not covered by financial aid. Students have to scramble for cover. Universities often prevent them from continuing their studies until their debts are settled. Then there’s the missing middle – the category of students NSFAS considers “very rich” funded by the aid scheme, but still struggling to scrape together the fees. The policy of free education is supposed to solve this, but in reality it does not work very well.

Accommodation is another issue. This has been an issue since the #FeesMustFall protests of 2015 and 2016 but has grown in popularity over the years. One of the main reasons is Zuma’s free education policy. A larger number of students have been allowed to enroll in higher education institutions, but provision is not being made adequately by universities and the government. This means that hundreds of students come to the university and have no place to stay.

This is the fundamental issue that has dominated student protests for the past four to five years. Students protested. University is coming up fast. Everything will go back to “normal”. But in the next academic year, the same problem arose again.

For anyone outside the university, the only images they will get are the ones that came out of the Wits protests that started last Wednesday. Students disrupted classes, vandalized property and took to the streets. There are murmurs on social media of “violent students”, “disruptive students”, “ungrateful” and so on. Lack of understanding of the structural issues that affect student access and success in higher education.

The latest protests reflect a shift in public sentiment. Although the #FeesMustFall protest was not universally received with enthusiasm by the public, by the end of the movement, there was a growing understanding of the issues facing students.

Today, many people don’t care about the protests. There was a general disturbance from the road closure, but most people who were not affected immediately saw it without feeling it. Any empathy and sympathy towards the students seems lacking. It may be due to the political and economic situation in the country, with many people facing the most difficult times. But this is ironic, because the reality of our campus is a microcosm of society as a whole.

For example, at the University of Johannesburg, one of the issues the students are working on is water supply. This is a situation many people in the city will find themselves in.

Universities also seem less interested in listening to students. They can’t bear all the burden for the complaints of the students but often seem not interested in knowing the people they have to serve.

Of course universities have to worry about loss of teaching and learning, property damage and so on. They may not get the support of the relevant government and ministries. Students are important to universities, but they are being criminalized by the institutions they are meant to help and teach. At iincreasing campus securitization has been noted for years as hiking violence on campus, but the university is not aware of it.

And the politicization of protest? The dynamic of student politics has changed a lot and is no longer dominated by student parties affiliated with the ANC. But those affiliated with the ruling party that is the student representative council are viewed with suspicion by other student parties. During the #FeesMustFall movement, students affiliated with the ruling party were accused of “selling out” and this sentiment continued.

Ultimately, lasting and sustainable solutions will be found only if all actors come to the table. Politicking should be left behind and students, higher education and training departments and vice-chancellors of all affected universities, including the private sector, should come together. Not like some failed conferences and indabas, but those with workable and sustainable solutions. You don’t have to take student protests so that all actors can act and make plans.

If not, the protests will continue and it will be anyone’s guess as to how this will turn out.

Fatima Moosa is a journalist and writer and is doing a master’s degree in international relations.

The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect official policy or position Mail & Guardians.



Source link

Leave a Reply