In the latest update on the SEC’s insider trading charges against former Coinbase Manager Ishan Wahi, the defendant asked the court to dismiss the case. According to filed a newthe defendants, Ishan and Nikhil Wahi, argued that the SEC’s allegations were false.
In the filing, counsel representing the former Coinbase employee said the cryptocurrency sold by the two brothers was not a security.
Details of SEC Executive’s Case Against Coinbase
On July 21, 2022, the US Securities and Exchange Commission filing insider trading charges against Ishan Wahi, a former manager of Coinbase, and his brother Nikhil Wahi in the District Court for the Western District of Washington.
According to the SEC’s argument, Ishan tipped off his brother Nikhil and friend Sameer Ramani with information about the name and timing of Coinbase’s upcoming token listing.
The filing also noted that Ishan communicated via phone and text messages using a non-US phone number, so US phone company records could not capture those conversations. The SEC further alleged that the trio made $1.1 million using Ishan’s tips.
The watchdog argued that Wahi and Ramani bought 25 cryptocurrencies before their official listing on Coinbase and sold them for a profit shortly after listing. Also, the SEC stated that at least nine cryptocurrencies are securities.
In more than 80-page new submission, Wahi’s lawyer highlights several reasons to imply that the Commission is wrong in its charges. First of all, these tokens are not securities because they do not have investment contracts.
He further emphasized that token developers have no obligation to buyers on the secondary market, adding that investment contracts cannot exist without contractual relationships.
Furthermore, Ishan’s lawyer notes that all the listings are utility tokens, stressing that their primary use is to promote activities on the platform and not investment products.
Lawyers Slam SEC For Enforcement Actions Without Clear Regulatory Authorization
The defendants’ lawyers criticized the SEC for several attempts to take over regulatory oversight of the young cryptocurrency industry through enforcement actions. In other words, the watchdog does not have clear congressional authority to determine which tokens are issued as securities.
According to them, the SEC should hold a public hearing or process that explains its view if it believes that digital assets are securities. Also, he advises the SEC to guide parties seeking regulation on the implications of offering and trading securities rather than jumping into enforcement action out of nowhere.
Earlier today, Caroline Pham, Commissioner of the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission, express concerns about the possible implications of the SEC case against Ishan Wahis on July 21, 2022. According to Pham, the SEC can only achieve regulatory clarity through a transparent and expert-supported process.
Wahis and Ramani also face charges by the US Attorney’s office for the Southern District of New York. On Thursday, July 21, 2022, Department of Justice declare that the US Attorney General and the Federal Bureau of Investigation filed charges against Ishan Wahi, Nakhil Wahi, and Sameer Ramani for conspiracy to commit wire fraud and scheme to conduct insider trading in crypto assets using Coinbase’s confidential information.
Meanwhile, Nikhil pleaded guilty to the charge in September and received a sentence of 10 months in prison for wire fraud conspiracy on January 10. His brother Ishan pleaded not guilty in August while Ramani remained on the run.
Featured image from Pixabay, QuinceCreative chart from TradingView.com