Andy Cohen do not buy The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City star Heather Gaythe story of how he got his famous black eye!
During the episode of Watch What Happens Live there, 54-year-old host asked the guest Lala Kentrung that she thought hurt Heather, and she seemed to support the fan theory that Mr. Shah responsible for what happened! At Vanderpump Rules answer:
“I think it’s from a cast member.”
Andy then made his thoughts on who was behind Heather’s injury clear, saying:
“From Jen Shah? Me too. I don’t think she hit her head on the dresser and got a scratch on her arm.
Related: Why Jen Turned Down Interview With Ex-Boss Andy Cohen!
For those who don’t know, the drama surrounding the 40-year-old personality played out during season 3 ROSLC. Heather woke up one day during the cast trip to San Diego sporting a badly bruised eye – and allegedly no idea how it happened! He claimed during the reunion:
“I fainted. I don’t know how it happened. I woke up terrified. My phone is plugged in, I’m in my pajamas”
As for her inconsistent claims? At Bad Mormons The author said he was “afraid” his friends would try to “rewrite the narrative” if they realized he couldn’t remember what happened. Heather continued:
“When the production came to my room, I told them, I said, ‘I have no idea, I have no memory.’ Then it spun out of control after that, and I took full responsibility, and I’m really sorry. It was scary. I knew I blacked out. I woke up in a very high stress situation with a lot of shame and humiliation. There was no way to hide , and I go to my thing, which is just humor and not lost, but I definitely do not want to involve anyone here, anyone in the production – that’s me. guilt and shame for not being able to explain.”
However, Heather contradicted herself as the incident unfolded, saying she couldn’t remember what happened but wanted the attacker to come forward. At the time, he also said he “doesn’t want women in trouble.” This, of course, left many cast members and fans confused. To make things even more suspicious, he contacts Jen to help him come up with a “good cover story.” Heather told the 49-year-old in the episode:
“I don’t want to bother anyone, Jen. That’s why I’m asking for your help, if anyone wants to talk about what happened yesterday.”
Although the couple kept the situation under wraps, Whitney Rosewho denied attacking Heather, believing that Jen was the culprit:
“I would think it was Jen. Like, what if Heather ticked off Jen, and Jen hit her? Did she think it would be a bad thing to test her?”
Angie Katsanevas it was even revealed that Jen was “quiet” and kept “by herself” the next day:
“[Shah gave off] a very dark feeling that there was something he knew that he didn’t share with the rest of the group.
However, Heather died theoretically in the reunion episode. While the mother of three noted that she would have no problem covering up for Jen if they were in a relationship, she insisted that was not the case:
“I trust her the most to do the cover story when you die and you have a black eye. If I knew Jen did that, I would cover it, but that’s not my intention – I don’t know.”
Andy noted that too Well done conducted an investigation into the jury – but they “found nothing, and there is no additional record.” Actually, the whole situation remains a giant mystery! But clearly, if you ask Andy for his thoughts on the matter, he supports the popular fan theory that Jen is!
What do you think, Perezcious readers? Do you believe Jen was behind Heather’s injury? Drop your thoughts on the ordeal in the comments below.
[Image via Bravo/YouTube, Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen/YouTube]