Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter.
Objects in the rear-view mirror may appear larger than they really are. A pending balance sheet restructuring at the private equity-owned software company Pluralsight has already attracted unusual attention.
The company’s $1.7bn debt is owned by some of the largest private asset managers in the world including Blue Owl, Oaktree and BlackRock. And earlier this year, its owners at Vista Equity Partners executed a complex debt reshuffle that hurt the seniority of those private lenders.
In widely held syndicated loans, financial sponsors have tended to play rough with creditors. However, the small club at Pluralsight believed that they were entitled to friendly treatment from Vista if there were bumps in the road for the company.
Pluralsight had been wobbling for some time. But the lender group apparently was keen to keep whistling past the graveyard. An FT review showed the marks the lenders shared through the reporting of their public affiliates put the debt at between 84 and 97 cents. Those heady levels cannot be reconciled with an unfolding situation where Vista has already marked its equity at 0 and is expected to soon hand over the Pluralsight keys to the lender group.
Two prominent academics have recently written a paper arguing that the shift to private credit, where loans are held to maturity by asset managers and away from publicly traded securities, will represent a sea change in how information about businesses becomes widely known to all stakeholders in the economy.
Specifically, without actively bought and sold term loans and high-yield bonds, there will be more Pluralsight situations where financial distress suddenly pops up, with no credit ratings, regulatory filings or secondary market prices to serve as warning shots.
Daily market trading can be criticised for representing more noise than signal. If a company is making its scheduled interest payments, its shifting enterprise value may not be so noteworthy. Managers can have the flexibility to make big operational and strategic changes without the pressure of marking to market spooking outsiders.
Still, owners and creditors will have somebody who is a client. What and how they share information about the status of an investment remains important. Regulators and policymakers, however, have limited ability to get involved. The worry is that the informational voids in this system could lead to painful shocks or sudden accidents.
sujeet.indap@ft.com